Enhancing Reflective Practice for Undergraduate Creative Arts Students

  • As an educator in the ever-evolving realm of creative disciplines, I am dedicated to refining my teaching methods to better equip my students for the dynamic world of creative practice. Central to this endeavour is the development of a reflective framework designed to deepen students' understanding of their creative processes and decision-making. This approach fosters critical self-analysis, encouraging them to become not only skilled practitioners but also thoughtful, introspective creators.

  • The purpose of this study is to propose a framework for encouraging reflective practice among undergraduate students enrolled in Creative Arts Programmes. The industry's dynamic nature, combined with technological advancements, puts increasing pressure on graduates to adapt to its demands. Students must emphasise innovation and originality in their work to succeed in this environment. While design schools teach students academic inquiry, research, design, and digital skills, the incorporation of reflective practice has emerged as an essential component in developing critical thinking within experiential learning contexts. However, the increasing emphasis on digital technology has shifted students' attention to acquiring digital skills, leaving little space and time for meaningful engagement in the design process. This paper seeks to investigate the limitations of traditional visual journals as a reflective tool and proposes a new framework for creative arts students that incorporates structured experiences, critical incidents, visual journals, and peer-to-peer reflection.

  • Overview of proposed study and framework

    Graduates of Creative Arts Programmes face increasing pressure to adapt to the industry's ever-changing demands, necessitating the development of skills that promote innovation and adaptability. Reflective practice has emerged as an essential component in fostering critical thinking within experiential learning contexts, and the purpose of this paper is to present a reflective framework that effectively improves the learning experience for creative arts students:

    Reflective Practice's Changing Role in Creative Arts Programmes: Design schools have traditionally focused on providing students with academic inquiry, research, design, and digital skills. While these abilities are necessary, incorporating reflective practice is becoming increasingly important. It is critical to foster innovation and originality during the design process, which ultimately influences the professionalism and success of the final product.

    Problems with Emphasising Reflective Practice: With the proliferation of digital technology, students' attention has shifted to acquiring digital skills and perfecting final products. As a result, the design process discourse, which provides a vital opportunity for deep learning, is frequently overlooked or underemphasised. This paper emphasises the importance of striking a balance between digital skill acquisition and reflective participation in the design process.

    Traditional Visual Journals Have Limitations: Creative arts schools have long used visual journals to encourage reflection. However, concerns have been raised about their effectiveness, including procrastination, superficial entries, waning enthusiasm, and a reluctance to reflect. As a result, alternative approaches are required to encourage meaningful reflection.

  • This study proposes a framework to address the limitations of traditional visual journals and improve the reflective practice of creative arts students. The framework's foundation consists of the following elements:

    Structured Experiences: Using structured experiences to help students analyse and synthesise difficult situations. This method provides a structure for in-depth reflection on specific developmental experiences.

    Critical Incidents: Using critical incidents in the design process encourages students to evaluate their decision-making and problem-solving abilities critically. This improves their ability to deal with complex challenges in the industry.

    Redefining the Visual Journal: Introducing a more structured and guided approach to using visual journals. Instead of superficial and unreflective entries, the new approach aims to elicit thoughtful reflections and meaningful insights.

    Peer-to-Peer Reflection: Facilitating reflection through peer groups allows students to participate in collaborative discussions, exchange feedback, and gain diverse perspectives on their work.

    Proposed Model

    The proposed model builds upon the conceptual framework and offers a structured approach to implementing reflective practice within creative arts programmes.

  • By incorporating structured experiences, critical incidents, a reimagined visual journal, and peer-to-peer reflection, the proposed framework aims to improve the reflective practice of undergraduate students enrolled in Creative Arts Programmes. This framework seeks to prepare students to meet industry challenges with innovation, adaptability, and a strong foundation in critical thinking by striking a balance between digital skill acquisition and reflective engagement with the design process. More research and evaluation will be conducted to determine the efficacy of this approach in enriching the learning experience of creative arts students.

“In its first manifestations, curiosity is a vital overflow, an expression of an abundant organic energy. A physiological uneasiness leads a child to be “into everything” — to be reaching, poking, pounding, prying… The most casual notice of the activities of a young child reveals a ceaseless display of exploring and testing activity. Objects are tasted, touched, and thumped; drawn and pushed; handled and thrown; in short, they are experimented with till they cease to yield new qualities. Such activities are hardly intellectual, and yet without them, intellectual activity would be feeble and intermittent through a lack of stuff for its operations.” John Dewey

This fascinating quote from John Dewey highlights the intrinsic nature of curiosity as an essential component of learning and development, particularly in young children. This curiosity, characterised by an unrelenting drive to explore, experiment, and understand the world, lays the groundwork for intellectual activity. It's through these exploratory activities that children engage with their environment, learning through interaction and experimentation.

In the context of reflective practice and its importance to creative students, Dewey's insights serve as a foundational concept. Reflective practice, much like the curiosity described by Dewey, is a process of continual learning and growth. It involves the critical examination of one's own thoughts and actions, leading to a deeper understanding of one's creative process. For students in creative fields, this reflective practice is not just beneficial but essential.

The design process, an integral part of creative disciplines, is inherently intertwined with reflective practice. It requires a constant cycle of ideation, experimentation, and reflection. Students engaged in creative activities often start with an idea, which they then explore through various means – much like the child in Dewey's description who experiments with objects in their environment. This exploration is a form of ideation, where new concepts and perspectives are generated.

As these ideas are brought to life through the design process, reflective practice becomes crucial. It allows students to critically assess their work, understand the choices they've made, and learn from both their successes and failures. This reflective process ensures that each step in the design journey is not just about producing an outcome but is also a learning experience in itself.

Therefore, Dewey's depiction of curiosity in young children can be seen as a metaphor for the journey of creative students. Just as a child learns about the world through active exploration and interaction, creative students develop their skills and understanding through a continuous process of ideation, design, and reflective practice. This cycle of learning is what drives innovation and personal growth, making reflective practice an indispensable element in the education of creative individuals.